Evaluation reports present the key results of an evaluation in written form. They are intended for use by:
- the stakeholders of an evaluation, in particular decision-makers, including those from BMZ, the development partners, and the German development cooperation agencies concerned;
- interested members of the public.
The executive summaries available on this website have been published as part of the series "BMZ Evaluation Reports" since 2005. Full reports are available upon request though usually in German except for international joint evaluations (eval@bmz.bund.de). The evaluation reports supply information on the strengths and weaknesses of the development interventions supported by BMZ. Furthermore, they provide decision-oriented recommendations and are thus an essential input for management deciding how to proceed in future.
BMZ evaluations are managed by an independent unit focussing on cross-cutting issues. These strategic evaluations serve the purpose of further developing or improving instruments, policies, and geographical and thematic strategies or programmes. Evaluations of an adequate sample of projects have been delegated to development cooperation agencies under their own responsibility. The quality, independence and utility of these evaluations are reviewed periodically.
In joint evaluations, BMZ cooperates with different partners in order to jointly assess specific aspects of development cooperation. Usually, BMZ's partners are other donors but also the governments of BMZ's partner countries are becoming increasingly involved. The degree of participation of BMZ varies: Sometimes it has a leading role (either alone or as member of the management group), in other cases other donors or partner countries have the lead with BMZ participating in the steering group.
BMZ evaluation reports in German can be found at Evaluierungsberichte.
BMZ Evaluation Reports (since 2006)
"Social Capacity Building" in Non-Governmental Development Cooperation
Summary Version of the Evaluation
BMZ Evaluation Reports 064, December 2011, 10 pages
An accessible version of the report is available on request.
jutta.wagner@bmz.bund.de
The "weltwärts" Development Volunteers Service
Summary
BMZ Evaluation Reports 057, December 2011, 13 pages
An accessible version of the report is available on request.
jutta.wagner@bmz.bund.de
The German Civil Peace Service
Synthesis Report
BMZ Evaluation Reports 055, April 2011, 12 pages
An accessible version of the report is available on request.
jutta.wagner@bmz.bund.de
InWEnt's International Leadership Training
Summary Version of the Evaluation
BMZ Evaluation Reports 052, October 2010, 9 pages
Assessing the Impact of Development Cooperation in North East Afghanistan 2005 – 2009
Final Report
BMZ Evaluation Reports 049, March 2010, 45 pages
Empowerment: The German Churches’ Programmes for the Participation of the Poor - Synthesis Report
Summary Version of the Evaluation
BMZ Evaluation Reports 048, February 2009, 10 pages
External Audit – Supreme Audit Institutions (SAIs) - Synthesis Report
Summary Version of the Evaluation
BMZ Evaluation Reports 046, February 2009, 8 pages
Evaluation in German Development Cooperation
A System’s Review
BMZ Evaluation Reports 044, July 2009, 20 pages
Introduction of Voluntary Social and Ecological Standards in Developing Countries
BMZ Evaluation Reports 043, October 2008, 22 pages
"The Engineering Capacity Building Program" in Ethiopia
BMZ Evaluation Reports 039, July 2008, 8 pages
Rural Development Support Program, Philippines
BMZ Evaluation Reports 030, July 2007, 8 pages
Assessing the Impact of Development Cooperation in North East Afghanistan
BMZ Evaluation Reports 028, September 2007, 24 pages
Taking Account of Gender Issues in German Development Cooperation: Promoting Gender Equality and Empowering Women
BMZ Evaluation Reports 027, September 2006, 9 pages
Country Programme Evaluation Bangladesh - Main Report
BMZ Evaluation Reports 026, March 2007, 10 pages
Returning Experts Programme - Synthesis
BMZ Evaluation Reports 025, March 2007, 9 pages
Training of Junior Experts in German Development Cooperation - Synthesis
BMZ Evaluation Reports 024, March 2007, 10 pages
Country Programme Evaluation Uganda - Priority Area Financial Sector Development
BMZ Evaluation Reports 023, March 2007, 11 pages
Evaluations (before 2006)
The following list contains strategic and project evaluations in English, which were managed by either BMZ or the implementing implementing organisations KfW Entwicklungsbank and GTZ up to 2005 with participation of BMZ's independent evaluation unit. Since 2005, project evaluations have been solely conducted and published by the implementing agencies. International joint evaluations are listed separately.
BMZ evaluation reports issued in German before 2005 can be found at Evaluierungsbericht vor 2006.
Education and Social Development Programme (PRODES)
December 2005, 5 pages
Sustainability of Regional Rural Development Programmes (RRD) - Country Case Study "Tanga Integrated Rural Development Programme (TIRDEP), Tanzania"
BMZ Evaluation Reports 007, July 2005, 14 pages
Sustainability of Regional Rural Development Programmes (RRD) - Country Case Study "Regional Rural Development Project (RRDP) Kandy, Sri Lanka"
BMZ Evaluation Reports 006, July 2005, 14 pages
Sustainability of Regional Rural Development Programmes (RRD)-Country Case Study "Integrated Rural Development Programme (IRDP) North Western Province, Zambia"
BMZ Evaluation Reports 005, July 2005, 8 pages
Sustainability of Regional Rural Development Programmes (RRD) - Country Case Study "Area Development Programme (ADP) West Pasaman, Indonesia"
BMZ Evaluation Reports 004, July 2005, 10 pages
Sustainability of Regional Rural Development Programmes (RRD) - Synthesis Report of Four Country Case Studies
BMZ Evaluation Reports 003, July 2005, 50 pages
Indonesian-German Environmental Programme Pro-LH - Indonesia
April 2005, 4 pages
Diocesan Development Programmes and Administration (Human Rights Programme, Diocesan Agricultural Development Programme, Women Empowerment Programme) - Ijebu-Ode, Nigeria
April 2005, 5 pages
Sustainable Management of Natural Resources in El Chaco - Sudamericano
April 2005, 5 pages
TC Legal Advisory Programme, PR China
March 2005, 5 pages
Boundless - Intercultural Learning in Dialogue, World University Service
February 2005, 5 pages
Promoting the Establishment of a Cadastral System in Cambodia
February 2005, 8 pages
Recultivation of the Desiccated Aral Sea Bed and Promotion of Private Agriculture
February 2005, 6 pages
Kooperationsvorhaben: Reconstruction of Rural Infrastructure in Sierra Leone
December 2004, 5 pages
Development of Rural Roads and Markets - Bangladesh
December 2004, 6 pages
Combating Youth Poverty
Synthesis Report, August 2004, 4 pages
Combating Youth Poverty – Field Study Guatemala
November 2003, 5 pages
Approaches to Reducing Youth Poverty in Cape Town - Field Study South Africa
December 2003, 4 pages
Combating Youth Poverty - Field Study Sri Lanka
December 2003, 4 pages
Combating Youth Poverty - Field Study Uganda
December 2003, 5 pages
Reaching Target Groups with Upgrading Programmes run by InWEnt
Cross-Section Evaluation
February 2004, 5 pages
Reaching Target Groups with Advanced Training Courses run by InWEnt - Partial Measure Promoting Municipal Administration - Field Study Philippines
February 2004, 4 pages
Reaching Target Groups with Advanced Training Courses run by CDG/DSE (InWEnt): Import Substitution/Export Promotion for Medium-sized Companies in Northern Namibia (CDG)
February 2004, 4 pages
Reaching Target Groups with Advanced Training Measures run by InWEnt - Partial Measure - Improving the Management of Small Development NGOs – Field Study Indonesia
February 2004, 4 pages
Reaching Target Groups with Advanced Training Courses run by CDG and DSE (InWEnt): Training Measure Management and Training in Namibian Local Government (DSE)
February 2004, 5 pages
Reaching Target Groups with Upgrading Programmes run by InWEnt: Training Measure Substainable Management of Water Resources in the SADC Countries (CDG) - Field Study Zambia
February 2004, 4 pages
Reaching Target Groups with Advanced Training Measures run by CDG and DSE (InWEnt) – Cleaner Production Training Measure (CDG) - Field Study Zambia
February 2004, 4 pages
Reaching Target Groups with Advanced Training Courses run by InWEnt – Partial Measure – Vocational Training Courses for Salesian Nuns – Field Study Philippines
February 2004, 4 pages
Priority Area: Environment Policy and Sustainable Use of Natural Resources – Field Study Madagascar
January 2004, 5 pages
Export Promotion in India - Indo-German Export Promotion Project (IGEP)
January 2004, 5 pages
HIV/AIDS Prevention and Control in Bilateral Programmes of German Development Co-operation
January 2004, 8 pages
Family Planning - Social Marketing of Contraceptives - Pakistan
December 2003, 5 pages
Poverty Alleviation and Support for Local Governance in the Nusa Tenggara Provinces - Indonesia
December 2003, 5 pages
Drinking Water Supply and Sanitation Projects in the Gouvernorate of kafr el sheikh - Egypt
December 2003, 4 pages
Decentralised Governance in Support of the National Poverty Reduction Strategy (PADEP) - Bolivia
December 2003, 6 pages
Rural Empowerment through Agrarian /Asset Development Program, Project Development Institute (PDI)/Manila
October 2003, 5 pages
Budget Support and Similar Instruments
Design Study, August 2003, 3 pages
German Bilateral Involvement in Poverty Reduction Strategy Processes - Field Study Bolivia
January 2003, 4 pages
German Bilateral Involvement in Poverty Reduction Strategy Processes - Field Study Honduras
January 2003, 3 pages
German Bilateral Participation in Poverty Reduction Strategy Processes - Field Study Zambia
April 2003, 5 pages
German Bilateral Participation in Poverty Reduction Strategy Processes - Field Study Tanzania
April 2003, 5 pages
German Bilateral Participation in Poverty Reduction Strategy Processes - Field Study Viet Nam
April 2003, 4 pages
German Bilateral Participation in Poverty Reduction Strategy Processes - Field Study Mauretania
April 2003, 5 pages
Tax Systems and Revenue Authorities in Developing and Transition Countries as an Instrument of Poverty Reduction
Synthesis Report, March 2003, 4 pages
Tax Systems and Revenue Authorities in Developing and Transition Countries as an Instrument of Poverty Reduction – Field Study: Advice on the Establishment of a Standardised Tax System for Bosnia and Herzegovina
March 2003, 4 pages
Tax Systems and Revenue Authorities in Developing and Transition Countries as an Instrument of Poverty Reduction – Field Study: Modernization of the Dominican Tax System
March 2003, 5 pages
Tax Systems and Revenue Authorities in Developing and Transition Countries as an Instrument of Poverty Reduction – Field Study: Advisory Services to Fiscal Administration in Nepal
March 2003, 5 pages
Tax Systems and Revenue Authorities in Developing and Transition Countries as an Instrument of Poverty Reduction – Field Study: Modernisation of the Nicaraguan Fiscal System
March 2003, 5 pages
Tax Systems and Revenue Authorities in Developing and Transition Countries as an Instrument of Poverty Reduction – Field Study: Advising Tanzania's Tax Administration
March 2003, 5 pages
Tax Systems and Revenue Authorities in Developing and Transition Countries as an Instrument of Poverty Reduction – Field Study: Advising Tanzania's Tax Administration
February 2003, 4 pages
Combined Financial and Technical Co-operation Project for a National Resource Protection Strategy in Paraguay (ENAPRENA)
January 2003, 6 pages
Rugmark and Care & Fair
January 2003, 4 pages
Ensuring the Participation of the Poor - Strengthening Good Governance - Case Study: Bibosi, Bolivia
January 2003, 5 pages
Public-Private Partnership (PPP)
Synthesis Report, January 2002, 5 pages
Public-Private Partnerships (PPP) - Study of the Fundamentals for the Evaluation
February 2002, 3 pages
Public-Private Partnership (PPP) - Country Study Albania
February 2002, 4 pages
Public-Private Partnership (PPP) - Country Study China
February 2002, 4 pages
Public-Private Partnership (PPP) - Country Study South Africa
February 2002, 5 pages
Public-Private Partnership (PPP) – Country Studies Thailand and Viet Nam
February 2002, 5 pages
Public-Private Partnership (PPP) - Country Study Uganda
February 2002, 4 pages
Public-Private Partnership (PPP) - Country Study Uganda
February 2002, 4 pages
Public-Private Partnership (PPP) - Country Study China
February 2002, 4 pages
Joint Evaluations
In joint evaluations, BMZ cooperates with different partners in order to jointly assess specific aspects of development cooperation. Usually, BMZ's partners are other donors but also the governments of BMZ's partner countries are becoming increasingly involved. The degree of participation of BMZ varies: Sometimes it has a leading role (either alone or as member of the management group), in other cases other donors or partner countries have the lead with BMZ participating in the steering group.
German Humanitarian Aid Abroad
Summary
December 2011, 15 pages
Die deutsche humanitäre Hilfe im Ausland
Kurzfassung der Evaluierung
Dezember 2011, 16 Seiten
The risk of vanishing effects
Impact evaluation of drinking water supply and sanitation programmes in rural Benin
November 2011, 200 pages
Le risque d’effets éphémères
Évaluation d’impact des programmes d’approvisionnement en eau potable et d’assainissement au Bénin
novembre 2011, 218 pages
The Evaluation of the Paris Declaration
Aiding the Peace
December 2010, 266 pages
Joint Evaluation of Citizens' Voice & Accountablility
November 2008, 134 pages
Country Case Study: Indonesia - Evaluation of Citizens' Voice & Accountablility
September 2008, 208 pages
The Paris Declaration. Evaluation of the Implementation of the Paris Declaration - Phase One: Synthesis Report
July 2008, 56 pages
The Paris Declaration. Evaluation of the Implementation of the Paris Declaration: Case Study of Germany
April 2008, 106 pages
Coordination, Complementarity and Coherence (3Cs): Evaluating Co-ordination, Complementarity and Coherence in EU Development Policy: A Synthesis
November 2007, 50 pages
The Health Sector in Tanzania, 1999 - 2006
International Joint Evaluation, October 2007, 171 pages
Provision of Technical Assistance Personnel in the Solomon Islands: What can we Learn from the RAMSI Experience?
September 2007, 76 pages
Technical Assistance in Viet Nam: Cooking Pho, Peeling Potatoes, and Abandoning Blueprints
September 2007, 102 pages
Synthesis Report: What can we Learn from Promising Experiences?
September 2007, 94 pages
Provision of Technical Assistance Personnel in Mozambique: Between 'Doing the Work' and a 'Hands-off' Approach
September 2007, 94 pages
Coordination, Complementarity and Coherence (3Cs): Evaluation of the EU Institutions and Member States' Mechanisms for Promoting Policy Coherence for Development
July 2007, 139 pages
Tsunami Evaluation Coalition - Joint evaluation of the international response to the Indian Ocean tsunami: Synthesis Report
Multi-project evaluations, July 2006, 178 pages
Tsunami Evaluation Coalition - Funding the tsunami response
Multi-project evaluations, July 2006, 59 pages
Tsunami Evaluation Coalition - Coordination of international humanitarian assistance in tsunami-affected countries
Multi-project evaluations, July 2006, 91 pages
Tsunami Evaluation Coalition - Links between relief, rehabilitation and development in the tsunami response
Multi-project evaluations, July 2006, 102 pages
Tsunami Evaluation Coalition - Impact of the tsunami response on local and national capacities
Multi-project evaluations, July 2006, 120 pages
Tsunami Evaluation Coalition - The role of needs assessment in the tsunami response
Multi-project evaluations, July 2006, 123 pages
Evaluation of General Budget Support:
Synthesis Report, May 2006, 354 pages
Evaluation of General Budget Support:
Burkina Faso Country Report, May 2006, 292 pages
Evaluation of the International Trade Centre UNCTAD/WTO (2006)
Synthesis Report
April 2006, 95 pages
Evaluation of General Budget Support
Malawi Country Report, May 2006, 191 pages
Evaluation of General Budget Support:
Mozambique Country Report, May 2006, 297 pages
Evaluation of General Budget Support:
Nicaragua Country Report, May 2006, 253 pages
Evaluation of General Budget Support:
Rwanda Country Report, May 2006, 268 pages
Evaluation of General Budget Support:
Uganda Country Report, May 2006, 330 pages
Evaluation of General Budget Support:
Viet Nam Country Report, May 2006, 219 pages
Review of German Government Funding for the Tsunami Relief Operations - Final Report
Multi-project evaluations, November 2005, 28 pages
Review of Funding from the General Public in Germany for the Tsunami Relief Operations
Multi-project evaluations, November 2005, 31 pages
Joint evaluation of effectiveness and impact of the enabling development policy of the world food programme (WFP) - Synthesis Report Volume 1, February 2005
Multi-project evaluations, February 2005, 80 pages
Joint Evaluation of effectiveness and impact of the enabling development policy of the world food programme (WFP) - Mali Country Study
Multi-project evaluations, December 2004, 76 pages
Joint Evaluation of effectiveness and impact of the enabling development policy of the world food programme (WFP) - Honduras Country Study
Multi-project evaluations, December 2004, 78 pages
Joint evaluation of effectiveness and impact of theenabling development policy of the world food programme (WFP) - Bangladesh Country Study
Multi-project evaluations, December 2004, 95 pages
Joint Evaluation of effectiveness and impact of the enabling development policy of the world food programme (WFP) - Pakistan Country Study
Multi-project evaluations, December 2004, 63 pages
Joint Evaluation of effectiveness and impact of the enabling development policy of the world food programme (WFP) - Ethiopia Country Study
Multi-project evaluations, December 2004, 83 pages
Joint evaluation of effectiveness and impact of theenabling development policy of the world food programme (WFP) - Bolivia Country Study
Multi-project evaluations, December 2004, 68 pages
Joint Evaluation of effectiveness and impact of the enabling development policy of the world food programme (WFP) - Mozambique Country Study
Multi-project evaluations, December 2004, 72 pages
Addressing the Reproductive Health Needs and Rights of Young People since ICPD - The Contribution of UNFPA and IPPF - Synthesis Report
Multi-project evaluations, January 2004, 89 pages
Local Solutions to Global Challenges: Towards Effective Partnership in Basic Education - Country Study Report - Uganda
September 2003, 136 pages
Addressing the Reproductive Health Needs and Rights of Young People since ICPD - The Contribution of UNFPA and IPPF - Bangladesh Country Evaluation Report
Multi-project evaluations, September 2003, 88 pages
Local Solutions to Global Challenges: Towards Effective Partnership in Basic Education - Country Study Report - Burkina Faso
September 2003, 174 pages
Addressing the Reproductive Health Needs and Rights of Young People since ICPD - The Contribution of UNFPA and IPPF - Tanzania Country Evaluation Report
Multi-project evaluations, September 2003, 98 pages
Addressing the Reproductive Health Needs and Rights of Young People since ICPD - The Contribution of UNFPA and IPPF - Viet Nam Country Evaluation Report
Multi-project evaluations, September 2003, 90 pages
Addressing the Reproductive Health Needs and Rights of Young People since ICPD - The Contribution of UNFPA and IPPF - Nicaragua Country Evaluation Report
Multi-project evaluations, September 2003, 103 pages
Local Solutions to Global Challenges: Towards Effective Partnership in Basic Education - Country Study Report - Bolivia
September 2003, 152 pages
Addressing the Reproductive Health Needs and Rights of Young People since ICPD - The Contribution of UNFPA and IPPF - Egypt Country Evaluation Report
Multi-project evaluations, September 2003, 78 pages
Addressing the Reproductive Health Needs and Rights of Young People since ICPD - The Contribution of UNFPA and IPPF - Burkina Faso Country Evaluation Report
Multi-project evaluations, September 2003, 71 pages
Local Solutions to Global Challenges: Towards Effective Partnership in Basic Education
Final Report
September 2003, 203 pages
Local Solutions to Global Challenges: Towards Effective Partnership in Basic Education - Country Study Report - Zambia
September 2003, 140 pages